In the early stages of a business, decisions are often made quickly.
A call is scheduled, terms are discussed, both parties agree, and the deal moves forward. There is a sense of trust, urgency, and mutual understanding. In many cases, this informal approach helps businesses move faster and close opportunities without delay.
But it also creates one of the most common and overlooked risks in business.
Because when things go wrong,
“we agreed on call” is not what gets enforced— the contract is.
The Legal Reality Behind Informal Agreements
Under Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, an agreement becomes a valid contract if it is made with free consent, lawful consideration, and lawful object.
This means even oral agreements can be legally valid.
However, enforceability in court depends on proof and clarity.
Further, under Section 91 and Section 92 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, when the terms of a contract are reduced to writing, oral evidence cannot be used to contradict or vary those written terms.
In simple terms:
If you have a written contract, the court relies on it.
If you don’t, proving your version becomes difficult.
As observed by Advocate Noopur Dave, Co-founder of Dave Associates, many disputes arise not because there was no agreement—but because the agreement was never clearly documented.
Where Informal Deals Start Failing Legally
1. Scope of Work: Uncertainty in Obligations
Courts require clear and definite obligations to enforce performance.
If scope is vague, enforcement becomes weak or impossible.
2. Payment Terms: Weak Recovery Position
Under contract law, recovery depends on clearly defined payment obligations.
Without timelines, milestones, or penalties, claims often become negotiation-based rather than enforceable.
3. Absence of Written Terms = Evidentiary Risk
Without documentation, parties rely on:
- emails
- chats
- call records
These may not conclusively establish contractual intent or detailed terms in court.
4. Termination & Exit: No Legal Clarity
In absence of termination clauses, parties fall back on general breach principles, which often lead to prolonged disputes and uncertainty.
5. Dispute Resolution: Litigation by Default
If no clause exists, disputes are governed by general civil jurisdiction.
However, structured clauses under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 allow:
- faster resolution
- controlled process
- reduced delays
Without it, businesses risk long-drawn litigation.
The Real Business Impact
The consequences are not just legal—they are commercial.
Businesses often face:
- Unrecovered payments
- Disputes over deliverables
- Delays in execution
- Increased legal costs
- Breakdown of business relationships
Under Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, compensation is awarded only for losses that can be proved.
Without clear contractual terms, proving such losses becomes significantly harder.
As highlighted by Advocate Noopur Dave, many businesses realise the importance of structured contracts only after entering disputes—when the cost of correction is far higher.
Why Written Contracts Strengthen Your Position
A well-drafted contract is not just documentation—it is legal leverage.
It clearly defines:
- Scope and deliverables
- Payment structure and timelines
- Liability and risk allocation
- Termination rights
- Dispute resolution mechanism
This ensures that in case of conflict, your position is clear, provable, and enforceable.
A Necessary Shift in Business Practice
Indian startups and businesses are gradually moving towards:
- Written agreements over verbal commitments
- Professionally drafted contracts
- Risk-based legal structuring
This shift reflects a practical reality:
legal clarity at the beginning prevents legal complications later.
Final Thought
Trust is important in business.
But trust alone does not protect your interests in law.
Because when a dispute reaches a legal forum,
it is not what was discussed on a call that matters—
it is what can be clearly proven and enforced.
Author
Advocate Noopur Dave is the Co-founder of Dave Associates, a Gujarat-based firm focusing on corporate contracts, entertainment, and fashion law, advising businesses on legal structuring and risk management.
Connect
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/noopur_dave_
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/adv-noopur-dave-6b5905187
.jpeg)
